主页 / server / 问题 / 1061283
Accepted
Aris Koutsoukis
Asked: 2021-04-23 23:00:15 +0800 CST

ExecStart 中的脚本退出时执行 ExecStop

  • 772

我对 systemd 服务的行为有点困惑。我有上述系统服务。

[Unit]
After=libvirtd.service

[Service]
Type=simple
Environment=VM_XML=xxxxxxx
ExecStartPre=/usr/bin/bash /usr/local/lib/common/createQcowImage.sh ${VM_XML}
ExecStart=/usr/bin/bash /usr/local/lib/common/createVM.sh ${VM_XML}
ExecStop=/usr/bin/bash /usr/local/lib/common/destroyVM.sh ${VM_XML}
Restart=always

[Install]
WantedBy=multi-user.target

当这个单元在 createVM.sh 脚本中启动时，它会创建一个 VM 并监控它的状态。如果 VM 的 PID 不再存在，则脚本以返回码 1 退出。我注意到，当发生这种情况时，ExecStop 被执行（我正在管理 /var/log/messages，当我手动销毁 VM 时）使用 virsh destroy 我在从 ExecStop 执行的脚本中播下用于调试的回声，以打印在 /var/log/messages 中）。这是 systemd 的默认行为吗？在单元退出时执行 ExecStop（我也尝试使用代码 0 退出，这是相同的行为）。这不是我真正想做的，因为在我销毁 VM 后，ExecStop 会尝试销毁导致 systemd 单元故障的同一 VM。有没有办法避免这种情况？

linux kvm-virtualization systemd

2 个回答

  1. Best Answer

    如果您想创建一个按预期运行的 systemd 服务配置，您需要很好地了解所有选项的含义。

    我建议您开始阅读man systemd.service有关Type=, ExecStart=, ExecStop=. 也许Type=exec，或者Type=oneshot更适合您的脚本？

    您描述的行为在我看来确实符合预期。

    要处理您的 VM 已被其用户停止的情况，您需要测试它是否仍在运行，如果没有则避免破坏它。也不要忘记 ExecStop 必须等待机器停止，而不仅仅是要求它停止。

    我附上了我用来启动 VirtualBox VM 的用户服务，也许你可以在那里找到一些灵感。

    [Unit]
Description=Virtual Machine as a headless service.
After=network.target virtualbox.target
Before=runlevel2.target shutdown.target

[Service]
Type=simple
Restart=no
Environment=VMNAME=my-vbox-vm
Environment=TIMEOUT=60
#ExecStartPre=VBoxManage snapshot $VMNAME take "before service start"
ExecStart=VBoxHeadless --startvm $VMNAME
# Sleep might be needed if there is some ExecStartPost later, to make sure that the VM was really powered up
#ExecStartPost=sleep 1
# sometimes it happens that the machine is paused from some reason
#ExecStartPost=bash -c "VBoxManage showvminfo $VMNAME | grep -E ^State:\\\\s+paused && VBoxManage controlvm $VMNAME resume || exit 0"
# If the VM uses the VirtualBox hdd encryption, so a line like below is needed to unlock the drive
#ExecStartPost=VBoxManage controlvm $VMNAME addencpassword $VMNAME "/home/user/VirtualBox VMs/my-vbxo-vm/my-vbox-vm.vmdk.pass"
# The 'savestate' is the only reliable way to turn off the machine.
# Optionally sending acpishutdown, can be considered, but better that needs to use the savestate as a fallback anyway,
# because the acpishutdown can be from various reasons ignored by the VM or delayed significantly.
#
# Alternatives for ExecStop
# - save state
#   (should be reliable but not really turning off the VM;
#    exit 0 necessary to handle the situation that VM was turned off already,
#    from inside)
#   ExecStop=bash -c "VBoxManage controlvm $VMNAME savestate || exit 0"
# - stop vm using acpi, with active waiting
#   (not reliable - if acpi signal ignored by VM, or shutdown takes too long,
#    systemd will just kill it after some timeout, (normally 90s);
#    note that the active waiting is necessary,
#    otherwise systemd might kill the process before shutdown is finished)
#   ExecStop=bash -c "VBoxManage controlvm $VMNAME acpipowerbutton && while (VBoxManage list runningvms | grep $VMNAME); do sleep 1; done"
# - stop vm using acpi or, after a timeout, with save state
#   (timeout let's say max 60s, to keep 30s for possible savestate;
#    exit 0 necessary in order not to have the service in error state when stopped already by acpi, or maybe even by user from inside of VM)
ExecStop=bash -c "VBoxManage controlvm $VMNAME acpipowerbutton && (let timeout=$TIMEOUT; while VBoxManage list runningvms | grep --silent $VMNAME && test $timeout -gt 0; do sleep 1; let timeout=$timeout-1; done) && VBoxManage list runningvms | grep --silent $VMNAME && VBoxManage controlvm $VMNAME savestate || exit 0"

[Install]
WantedBy=default.target
    • 0

  2. 这是 systemd 的默认行为

    当使用ExecStart配置的进程是服务的主进程时，使用type=simple（默认设置）。此类单元将等到 ExecStart 指定的进程返回，然后通过运行 ExecStop 指定的进程来停用

    我设法通过在从 ExecStop 执行的脚本中添加一个小检查来解决我的问题，以便仅在 VM 存在时才销毁 VM。

    DOMAIN="$(xmllint --xpath '//domain/name/text()' $1)"
tmp=$(/usr/bin/virsh list --all | grep "$DOMAIN" | awk '{ print $3}')
if ([ "$tmp" != "" ]);then
    echo "Destroying $DOMAIN"
    /usr/bin/virsh destroy $(xmllint --xpath '//domain/name/text()' $1)
fi
    • 0

相关问题